Section 106 is under attack

from three directions at once.

Each battlefront requires a different response—but all three are part of the same fight to preserve the Tribal Nations’, affected communities’, and the public’s right to know, participate, and be heard before irreplaceable places are harmed.

01

The Executive Branch is evading or compressing review for individual projects.

02

The Advisory Council on Historic Preservation is attempting to rewrite the regulations that make Section 106 work.

03

Congress will soon vote on statutory changes that would gut that National Historic Preservation Act

GUTTING THE STATUTE

THE THREAT

Senators Lee, Capito, Heinrich, and Whitehouse have introduced the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA), which would gut Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act.  Its sponsors say it will accelerate infrastructure while preserving environmental and historic preservation processes and formal Tribal consultation. We have read the statutory language. Each of those claims is a lie.

The bill cuts the public out of consultation entirely. It makes Tribal consultation meaningless and assaults Tribal and state sovereignty: if a Tribal Nation or SHPO doesn't do what the federal government wants, when it wants it, the government can seize control of those offices and withhold funds. It narrows the definition of a federal undertaking such that Section 106 will hardly apply. It makes avoidance, minimization, or mitigation of adverse effects optional. And it expands unilateral agency authority and restricts judicial review for all of us, while giving developers the power to sue to enforce timelines.

Ironically, each of those changes will slow development. Key terms are left undefined. Drafters say they couldn’t agree so the courts will have to sort it out. Developers are going to destroy places and people are going to find out as they are being destroyed. Communities will protest and the bill provides no way to resolve conflict.

106 Strong calls on Senators to vote “no” on this disastrous bill and to reconvene in a new Congress to tackle permitting reform with transparency and integrity.

slashing THE REGULATIONS

THE THREAT

The Advisory Council on Historic Preservation—the federal agency created to help carry out the National Historic Preservation Act—is pursuing sweeping changes to the regulations governing Section 106. The reported proposals could give agencies greater power to decide whether the public receives notice, narrow the places and harms considered, weaken Tribal and community participation, and reduce the expectation that agencies seek ways to avoid, minimize, or mitigate damage.

These are not technical adjustments. The regulations determine who is heard, what agencies must examine, which places receive consideration, and whether consultation has any meaningful connection to the final decision. Rewriting them could weaken Section 106 for every federally connected project in the country without Congress ever voting to change the law.

You can read the redlined version here and the draft here.

Executive End Runs around THE LAW

THE THREAT

Across the country, federal officials are finding ways to build first and consult later. Agencies have invoked “emergency” procedures, narrowed the scope of review, limited public participation, withheld information, and advanced projects before affected Tribal Nations and communities have a meaningful opportunity to respond.

The consequences are already visible—from the demolition of the White House East Wing and proposed transformations of the Kennedy Center and Eisenhower Executive Office Building to the President’s triumphal arch and hundreds of projects being accelerated using the unsubstantiated declaration of an energy emergency nationwide. Once a building is demolished, a burial ground disturbed, or a sacred landscape permanently altered, no later explanation or court ruling can restore what was lost.

One Fight: Three Fronts

The form of the attack may change, but the objective of the opponents of the National Historic Preservation Act is the same: reduce the obligation of federal agencies to look, listen, and consider consequences before they act. Meeting a three-front attack requires a unified strategy—defending the law in Congress, protecting meaningful regulations, challenging unlawful executive action, and building a stronger Section 106 system for the future.